The role of a recruiter in an AI-driven world.

Artificial intelligence is rapidly changing how we work, and as a recruiter, I’m at the forefront of this transformation. AI-powered tools are now critical for my day-to-day activities, speeding up candidate submissions and reviews. They can screen hundreds of resumes in minutes and identify candidates who have the matched experience my clients need. This efficiency is a massive advantage in a competitive market.

Still, it brings up an important question: what is my role as a human recruiter when a machine can do so much?

The answer lies in a powerful partnership. The most successful recruiting happens when you pair the speed and accuracy of AI with the experience and intuition of a skilled recruiter. AI can find the candidates who look great on paper, but it takes a human touch to discover the creativity, passion, and cultural fit that make a candidate truly exceptional. This is the “it factor” that leads to campaigns with surprise and delight. This post explores how I make that magic happen.

The power of pairing AI with human expertise

In modern recruitment, AI offers powerful solutions for streamlining the hiring process. It manages the initial, time-consuming stages, like sifting through applications to find those with the right match of experience. This machine matching is vital for faster, more accurate submittals, and it frees me up to focus on what I do best: building relationships and making nuanced evaluations.

Emerging role: AI Trainer.

article

However, a total reliance on AI can lead to generic, uninspired outcomes. When a process is fully automated, the unique, creative spark that drives innovation can get lost. AI can confirm if a candidate has the required hard skills, but it can’t gauge their problem-solving abilities, communication style, or potential to bring fresh ideas to the table. That’s where I come in.

I use AI as a highly efficient assistant. It supports me by managing tasks like drafting emails or providing a second look at resumes. This support allows me to dedicate my energy to more strategic activities where human connection is key. While an AI might flag a resume as promising, I’m the one who engages with the candidate through phone screenings and virtual interviews. These personal interactions are essential for assessing the soft skills that AI can’t measure.

My process: spotting the “it” factor

Uncovering a candidate’s creative potential and cultural fit requires me to look beyond their resume. It’s about understanding their motivations, their passions, and how their personal experiences align with a company’s mission. I do this by asking insightful questions and listening for the stories behind the experience.

10 ways humans are better than an AI Interviewer.

article

Consider the challenge I faced when finding a Photo Production Assistant for a prominent pet company’s team in Dallas, a city not known as a primary hub for this specific talent pool. Finding someone with the right experience was difficult. I connected with a candidate whose resume showed promise but didn’t tell the whole story. An AI tool might have flagged her for the right experience, but it couldn’t have uncovered her passion.

Through a series of thoughtful questions during the screening process, I discovered her deep-seated love for production. She shared stories of growing up on movie sets with her father, where she was fascinated by how different teams collaborated to create a single project.

She spoke of her love for organization and her experience building large-scale art installations, demonstrating a perfectionist’s eye for detail. Her internship at a fashion design house further revealed her willingness to jump in wherever needed, from organizing fabrics to dressing models for a fashion show.

These details (her collaborative spirit, hands-on experience, and intrinsic motivation) were qualities an AI would have missed. My ability to ask the right questions and listen to the stories behind the resume revealed a candidate who was not just qualified, but a perfect fit for the creative and collaborative environment at my client’s company. This is the art of recruiting.

How I uncover hidden potential with the right questions

So, how do I effectively identify these uniquely human qualities? It starts with asking better questions. While AI can screen for matching experience, I can probe for passion, creativity, and drive. The key is to move beyond the resume and into real-world scenarios and personal motivations.

Here are three questions that I use to uncover a candidate’s soft skills and alignment with a company’s goals:

“Tell me about a time you identified an opportunity in business. What was the issue, how did you resolve it in a creative way, and what was the outcome?”

This single question can reveal a candidate’s problem-solving skills, critical thinking, and communication style. For example, a candidate for a Creative Project Manager role at a large retail company shared how she identified a misalignment in marketing strategies at a previous job with a Fortune 500 company. She took the initiative to create an integrated marketing calendar and launch tracker, which streamlined the entire process. This story showcased creative thinking and leadership that a simple resume line item couldn’t convey.

“What inspires and motivates you in your work?”

This question moves beyond skills and experience to explore a candidate’s inner drive. Their answer can show whether their personal passions align with the company’s mission and values. It helps me understand if the candidate is just looking for a job or if they are truly invested in the work and the industry.

How to go beyond resumes for data-driven recruiting. 

article

For example, I recently asked a candidate about their favorite project. They described leading the innovation team at National Geographic to create the organization’s first interactive digital experience, the “American Nile” project. This project highlighted the severe decline of the Colorado River due to man-made conditions, detailing the devastating impact on local wildlife and communities.

While the project won several awards, including a Webby, that wasn’t why it was their favorite. What made it meaningful was its real-world impact. The project was displayed on screens during congressional proceedings, referenced by legislators to justify securing millions of dollars in funding for conservation efforts.

The candidate explained that it was their favorite project because it “literally saved lives.” This kind of answer reveals a deep sense of purpose and a desire to create work that has a tangible, positive impact—a quality that goes far beyond a resume.

“Are you familiar with our brand / product? What is your experience with it?”

For consumer-facing brands, this can be particularly telling. A candidate who is already a passionate user of a product brings an authentic connection and a deeper understanding of the end user. As I’ve often found, this personal alignment “starts the passion of it all” and can be a powerful asset that a resume alone cannot convey.

Hiring managers often provide a job description outlining hard skills, but it’s crucial for me to dig deeper. Understanding the team’s culture, the business’s values, and the intangible qualities that lead to success in a role is just as important as ticking off technical qualifications.

The future of recruiting is human curiosity

My work doesn’t end with a checklist of skills and experiences. It’s driven by my own sense of curiosity. I continually strive to learn more about the hiring manager, their team dynamics, and the specific challenges they face. This allows me to understand their needs on a much deeper level than any job description could provide. I’m not just filling a role; I’m helping to build a more effective team.

This same curiosity extends to how I approach candidates. Getting to know them beyond their resume is fundamental. I want to understand what drives them, what kind of environment they thrive in, and what makes them feel fulfilled in their work. For me, getting the right fit the first time is critically important. It’s not just about ensuring my client’s success—it’s also about securing the talent’s long-term happiness and professional growth. This dual focus is what turns a good placement into a great one. In an AI-driven world, it’s this deeply human connection that makes all the difference.